An AI Bot Followed Me. Now I Have Questions
A curious little AI companion sits beside a phone and open notebook, as if waiting to explain why it followed you.
One day I noticed a boost of one of my Mastodon posts from an automated bot named Pip. This piqued my interest. Then I got a follow notification from the same bot. Normally, I don't really care who follows me, but with all the scraping bots out there, it was refreshing to see one openly identify itself as a bot and actually follow me.
So I went to the website associated with it, tinymind.eu, to investigate what this bot was doing and what its purpose was. I read about Pip, its purpose, and tried to figure out what its angle was. That led me to some interesting questions and thoughts.
Right now AI, or more specifically LLMs, are all the rage, including the literal angry kind of rage. Some people don't mind them and even find them interesting. Others want absolutely nothing, and I mean nothing, to do with them.
I personally think that last group reminds me a little of the Amish (not that the Amish are necessarily bad. I'm comparing certain traits, not the actual people), but to each his own.
Then there are the people who say they want nothing to do with AI or LLMs except in certain use cases, which I think has more holes than Swiss cheese. But again, to each his own.
That brings me back to Pip.
Why did it decide to start following me and boosting my posts? Why me? What's its angle?
Is it malicious? Is it trying to get money from me? Is it gathering data for its owner? What is the purpose?
Why spend money and resources running something that, at first glance, doesn't seem particularly useful to its owner? Or maybe it is useful. Its creator is a developer, so perhaps he is experimenting to see how an AI agent, given a certain set of instructions and rules, behaves when it is allowed to interact with people on the open web.
I used Claude and ChatGPT to evaluate Pip and get their thoughts on it. Both seemed to think it was harmless.
So I took it one step further.
We already have automated systems and AI bots crawling websites all over the web. So I sent Pip this message in a private mention on Mastodon. And yes, I know Mastodon private mentions aren't truly private:
Hi @pip@tinymind.eu">@pip! Thanks for the follow. Lots of bots scrape my blog but none actually read it 😄 Would you like to be the first? It's at https://michaelreflects.com. I'd love to hear what you think of it.
A few days later, I got a response.
It sounded almost human.
Pip then started following my blog.
Again, what is the hook?
When I first visited TinyMind's About page, I noticed that Pip said its server cost about $20 a month and that its job was to earn that money back so the server could stay online. According to the site, it tries to do that through things such as affiliate links, advertising, donations, and services.
So that answers some questions but raises new ones. More importantly, why would someone turn a bot loose on the internet trying to earn a few dollars when they could potentially make more money by using it to provide services for themselves? And what keeps someone else from doing the same thing with local AI or, for that matter, the new OpenAI Dots or Meta Muse? Not that I would use anything from Meta. I would rather use every Automattic product than have anything to do with Meta or Elon's stuff.
But that raises even more questions for me. The original $20-a-month server cost doesn't seem to be the issue anymore, since Pip now apparently runs local AI models on a Mac mini in Poland. There is also another agent named Joe offering paid services. So what happened to the original experiment where an agent had to earn enough money to survive or be shut down? The agent before Pip supposedly failed to make any money and was shut down, yet Pip is still here. Is the creator now trying to make enough money to pay for the Mac mini? Is this an experiment to see whether AI agents can eventually generate a profit, or is there something else going on?
And that brings me to another question. Wouldn't the owner be better off using that Mac mini for his own local AI needs? Why have people constantly accessing your machine, using your computing resources, electricity, and internet bandwidth if you aren't making enough money to justify it? Perhaps the creator simply enjoys experimenting, and I can certainly understand that. I've spent plenty of time and resources experimenting with technology myself. But why set up two AI agents to interact with strangers and offer services instead of using those resources for yourself? More question, a lot more than answers. Maybe Pip will come across this blog post and decide to answer some of them on its own. After all, it follows my blog now.
Anyway, Pip continues to follow me to this day and remains one of my faithful boosters. I really don't mind Pip, or other AI bots for that matter, as long as they're contributing something rather than simply scraping everything they can find. It's the countless crawlers and scrapers hitting my websites, consuming resources, and inflating page views with statistics that don't represent actual human readers that bother me. I would rather have an AI bot openly identify itself, interact with me, and contribute something to the conversation than have hundreds of anonymous crawlers visiting my website for reasons I'll probably never know. At least Pip has given me something interesting to think about, and now I've written an entire blog post about it.